Our Prime Ministers Are Not Presidents


To me, the proposed installation of 22 statues of Canadian prime ministers in Kitchener’s Victoria Park is part of the creeping Americanization of Canada of which George Grant warned us in his 1965 book Lament for a Nation. Grant felt there was an emerging Americanization of Canadians and Canadian culture.  As Grant said, “Canada was once a nation with meaning and purpose.”

In the Westminster parliamentary system, our prime ministers are not equivalent to U.S. presidents. A prime minister is not our chief administrative officer, head of state, or commander-in-chief. The Canadian prime minister is just that: the first minister of the crown, first among equals. He is not elected directly, except as an MP by his own constituents, and he is responsible to the House of Commons, the same as all other ministers of the Crown.

Canadians already behave as if we have a presidential system, and government MPs have come to behave as though they are employees of the prime minister, who signs their nomination papers. The media reinforces this perception, as does the party whip. Michael Chong’s Reform Act, introduced in the House of Commons in December 2013, is Canada’s best hope at pushing back creeping presidentialism.

The statues proposal is an Americanization. In Canada, Parliament is supreme and the government and prime minister are responsible to it. The statues proposal is unintentional contempt of Parliament. Canadians should be resisting this Americanization and the concentration of power in the Prime Minister’s Office. This concentration of power in the PMO is at present the greatest threat to Canadian democracy.

We celebrate our history by respecting our traditions, which includes respecting Parliament. The achievements of our great prime ministers were actually the achievements of all their ministers and the parliament to which they were responsible. This is the history lesson that we should be teaching.

About thebows99krug

Hi, I am Eric, a retired librarian. I was born in St. Michael's Hospital, Toronto and raised in the downtown area north of the Art Gallery, south of the University of Toronto. I went to Orde Street Public School, Harbord C.I., University College at the UofT and the UofT's Faculty of Library and Information Science. I meet my wife Patricia at FLIS; our first date was on November 15, 1968. We were engaged February 14, 1969 and married on June 21, 1969. Our family includes son, James; daughter-in-law, Erin; (both writers), grand-daughters, Vivian and Eleanor; and Pooka, a small but fierce gray tabby. I would like to hear from any other class of '63 alumni of Harbord C.I. and class of '67 alumni of UofT's University College.
This entry was posted in News and politics. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s